|
Caterpillars,
Butterflies, and Sector Rotation
From
1931 to 1959, US Steel (X) climbed
from $2.50 to $75. Since then, the
stock hasn't been much of a profit
maker for stockholders except for a
brief show of strength in 1974 and
1975. The rest of the time it wallowed
around in the low double digits as
domestic steel went into a nosedive.
That was until
recently. From its bottom in 2003 of
around $10, the stock has climbed
steadily until it hit $77.77 on
Thursday.
Up until the mid-1980s, telephone
utilities were the stocks of widows
and orphans, as they say. Steady dividend
payers, but in a word - Dull. Then
something happened unbeknownst to most
investors. Steadily, these once-stodgy
stocks began to come alive. By the
1990s, telephone utility stocks were
rebranded Telecommunications stocks,
fully ready to take advantage of the
Internet runup.
The fact of the matter is that we
seldom understand or appreciate what
is happening beneath our noses. Only
in retrospect do we see what we should
have seen. Whether is was telecom
stocks a decade ago, or a basic
industry stock a few years ago, the
message of the market always is
"change."
This is not acceptable thinking to
indexers or long-term-buy-and-holders.
They want to believe that once a
decision to invest in the stock market
is made, there's nothing else to do
except sit back and enjoy the ride,
bumpy as it is. They refuse to accept
that strong industry and sector groups
come and go. They don't realize that
to get their beloved
"average" return, some areas
of the market must outperform and some
must under perform. You should always
be concentrating your funds in the
"outperforming" groups.
Five years ago you couldn't have given
gold stocks away even if you threw in
a free toaster. Today, you can't get
enough of them. Call it Schumpeter's
"creative destruction" if
you will, but an easier term would be
simple sector rotation. Fads and
herding are a basic part of the human
psyche, and the stock market is no
more immune than are Beatle Boots,
Leisure Suits, Beanie Babies, and
SUVs. Profitable stock market
investors understand the landscape
they walk on and are ever aware of the
changing financial/economic
scene.
What'll be the leading sectors of a
year from now? Only a fool would even
try to make that prediction. But the
best places to have put your money
will be telegraphing their strength in
the charts long before they become #1.
So don't step on that caterpillar
because it'll be a butterfly before
long. Like USG (formally US Gypsum)
which rose from $3 in 2003 to $120
last week thanks to favorable court
rulings and a resurgent building
sector. Renewal and decay are always
the order of the land, and the stock
market.
An interesting side note came out of
the Berkshire Hathaway annual meeting
recently when both Buffett and Munger
remarked that at one time in their
lives they believed in the concept of bulletproof
franchises. Sadly, they've gone the
way of the Dodo bird...that is if they
ever existed in the first place. Their
bulletproof franchises, newspapers for
Buffett, and GM for Munger, are being supplanted
by the next new thing. And so it will
ever be.
Growth
or Value
The
question frequently arises as to which
area one should put their money. Media
analysts constantly weigh in with
their favorite, recommending either
one or the other. We must never forget
that a profit is accomplished when you
purchase a security for a lower price
then sell it at a higher price. Profit
knows not growth, value, cyclical, or
dividend payer. Profit knows only
the math of addition and
subtraction.
Simplespreaders would be well served
by putting their hands over their ears
when in the presence of such debates.
A strong stock in a strong industry in
a strong sector is a good potential
profit regardless what class of
investment it falls into. So, as you
listen to the various comments by the
media analysts, don't lose sight of
market reality.
Parabolic
Curves
Joe
Granville popularized the notion that
an increasingly vertical price
movement (parabolic curve) signaled
the imminent end of a rally. If a
parabolic curve isn't what we've just
witnessed in the Metals, Energy, and
some Construction stocks, then I don't
know what it is.
FOR
THE WEEK...Whacko!
THE
TOP TEN...
|
Sector |
12Novt05
to
12May06 |
Week
of
12 May 06 |
Visual
Chartist Commentary
|
|
Metals
& Mining |
+49.7%
|
-1.57% |
Industrial
Metals suffered biggest
losses. Precious Metals also
were hit hard. The whole
sector has been on a parabolic
tear. See above remarks
about parabolic curves. |
|
Manufacturing |
+28.6% |
-3.46% |
Recent
selloff hasn't put much of a
dent into these stocks. A few
strong stocks are at support.
|
|
Aerospace/Defense
|
+21.3% |
-2.56% |
Everything
still in strong uptrends. Few
stocks at areas of support. |
|
Transportation |
+20.8% |
-3.08% |
A
few stocks have dropped down
to support. Many more are
still extended well above
support. Speaking of the
changing fortunes of sectors
above, few industries can
match the 700% increase of the
Railroads since 2000. Reminiscent
of the dot.com era. Traffic?
|
|
Automotive
|
+20.6% |
-3.45%
|
Again,
only a few foreign
manufacturers are keeping this
group among the leaders.
|
|
Energy |
+19.9% |
-3.43% |
Parabolic
moves are manifested in almost
every industry. |
|
Materials
& Construction
|
+18.3% |
-3.54%
|
Residential
Construction looks like an egg
ready to roll off the table and
go splat on the floor.
Very surprising this sector has
held onto its strength as long
as it has.
|
|
Leisure |
+17.8% |
-2.15% |
300%
gains in Hotels and Gaming
Activities since 2003 place
current prices far above
meaningful support.
|
|
Consumer
Durables
|
+15.6% |
-3.81%
|
Still
a long ways off of its 2000
high. Charts don't look that
encouraging.
|
|
Electronics |
+15.2% |
-5.98% |
Barely
hanging onto a Top Ten spot.
Really got whacked this week,
but some selected stocks still
look promising.
|
|
AND THE
REST... |
|
Chemicals
|
+15.1% |
-2.16%
|
Trying
to regain former glories. A lot
of basic industry stuff here
that wants to be like
Manufacturing.
|
|
Conglomerates
|
+14.6% |
-2.15%
|
First
time these stocks have caught
good bids in a while. Some good
looking stocks here too.
|
|
Banking
|
+14.1% |
-2.50%
|
Just
not volatile enough for
Simplespreaders right now. Plus,
it looks like its weakening.
|
|
Real Estate
|
+11.9% |
-2.34%
|
Old
strength dies hard. Keeps coming
back but then weakens quickly
after a short spurt. Don't see
much future here.
|
|
Telecommunications
|
+11.5% |
-3.16%
|
Has
been on steady incline along
with rest of market. Nothing
outstanding.
|
|
Financial
Services
|
+10.6% |
-3.42%
|
Weakening
rapidly after end-of-year run.
|
|
Consumer
Non-Durables
|
+10.3% |
-2.63%
|
Multi-year
weakness in the face of our
recovery from the 2002 lows is
quite normal. Look for signs of
strengthening if the market does
a swan dive.
|
|
Food &
Beverage
|
+9.6% |
-0.59%
|
Finally
making a move. Keep your eyes
here, but few good options
stocks.
|
|
Computer
Hardware
|
+9.1% |
-5.11%
|
Rallies
to the vicinities of 2004 highs
brings it to decision
time. Does it keep going or turn
around and head back down?
|
|
Media
|
+9.0% |
-0.29%
|
Some
stirrings here, along with Food
& Beverage and Utilities.
For the first time in a long
time, the bear market hedges are
awakening from their sleep.
|
|
Dow Jones Ind.
Avg.
|
+7.9% |
-1.7%
|
Has
support right here, but any
rally could very well fail
considering the weakness of the
rest of the market.
|
|
Utilities
|
+7.8% |
-2.78%
|
Weak,
but steadily improving since the
first of April.
|
|
Diversified
Services
|
+7.8% |
-1.84%
|
Nothing
here to recommend it at all.
|
|
Specialty
Retail
|
+7.7% |
-2.19%
|
The
momentary rally was nothing to
get excited about. Still looks
weak.
|
|
Insurance |
+7.4% |
-1.56% |
Along
with rest of money affected
sectors, not looking that
great. Poor volatility. |
|
Wholesale |
+6.6% |
-3.09% |
Steadily
weakening since last fall. |
|
Tobacco |
+6.5% |
-2.87% |
Typically
a bear market hedge, but is
still napping. |
|
Drugs |
+5.5% |
-1.98% |
What
else can go wrong? Everything? |
|
Computer
Software & Svcs |
+5.2% |
-3.75% |
Couldn't
catch a bid when Electronics
sprang to life. |
|
Retail |
+5.0% |
-3.10% |
Looking
worse and worse. |
|
Health
Services |
-1.9% |
-0.46% |
Next
to last and down on the
year. |
|
Internet |
-4.7% |
-5.63% |
Dead
last and the only other sector
to be actually down for the
year. |
|