|
Non-Random
Oily Profits
A
former secretary of the Treasury is
reputed to have said that the
Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH), more popularly known as the Random Walk, is
the worst mistake economics has ever
made. Additionally, a famous and
successful money manager is rumored to
have said that the Efficient Market Hypothesis
(Random Walk) is a case of dementia. Whether wrong
or sick, EMH - Random Walk has visited disease upon
investors for some 30 years.
Example:
Over
the past two years, oil and oil
related securities have trended higher
and higher in an non-random manner. Investors had a choice in
January 2004: they could follow the
siren's call to be average by putting
their money into index funds, or they
could have put their money into strong
stocks in strong industries in a (demonstrably)
strong sector - Energy. The table
below shows how they would have fared.
|
Index |
Jan
2004 - May 2006 |
| Dow Jones
Industrial Average |
+8% |
| S & P 500
Index (Most
Indexers) |
+14% |
| NASDAQ |
+7% |
| S & P 400
Mid-Cap Index |
+34% |
| S & P 600
Small Cap Index |
+40% |
| Philadelphia
Oil Service Index |
+140% |
The
chart below shows how consistently the
energy sector climbed ever upward over
this 2-year period, taking practically
every energy related stock with it.

Was
this profit area difficult to predict?
No.
The
table below shows how the Energy
sector consistently attained Top Ten
status over the 2 years in question. For the past 29
months, with the exception of February
and March of this year, Energy has
been one of the Top Ten places to have
put your money. Numerous Simplespreads
have been available netting astute
investors plenty of cash in their
pockets.
|
Energy
Sector Monthly Relative
Strength Ranking |
|
2004 |
2005 |
2006 |
| J |
F |
M |
A |
M |
J |
J |
A |
S |
O |
N |
D |
J |
F |
M |
A |
M |
J |
J |
A |
S |
O |
N |
D |
J |
F |
M |
A |
M |
| 7 |
9 |
7 |
2 |
2 |
7 |
1 |
3 |
1 |
4 |
2 |
8 |
10 |
1 |
3 |
3 |
5 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
2 |
4 |
2 |
28 |
28 |
7 |
4 |
Turning to specific
stocks, the table below highlights a
small sample of the vast (and high
profile) opportunities
that have been available to investors
who use the correct screening filters to
find profitable situations:
|
Stock |
Jan 2004 - May 2006 |
| Frontier Oil
Corp. |
662% |
| Valero Energy
Corp. |
397% |
| Transocean Inc. |
243% |
| Weatherford
International Ltd. |
185% |
| Halliburton Co. |
175% |
| Helmerich &
Payne Inc. |
175% |
| Schlumberger
Ltd. |
157% |
| Oceaneering
International |
148% |
| Baker Hughes
Inc. |
147% |
| Marathon Oil
Group |
136% |
| Kerr-McGee Corp. |
133% |
| Anadarko
Petroleum Corp. |
109% |
Each
of these stocks provided Simplespreaders
with opportunities (plural)
for profitable option writing profits.
Their charts showed stair-step
patterns of higher highs and higher
lows. They were strong, market leading
stocks, and usually, they had juicy call
options available for the
selling.
Of
the 233 stocks in the Energy complex
since January 2004, 210 (or 90%) rose
in price during the time covered by
our discussion. However, for the rest
of the market, of a total of 6200+
stocks, less than 3800 of them rose in
price,
or something in the vicinity of 60%.
Bottom
line: Over the past 2 years, about 90%
of Energy stocks rose in price, many
of them well in excess of 100%. During
the same time, of all stocks, only
about 60% rose in price. There was
nothing mysterious about the oil
rally. Strong performing stocks
created a strong uptrend. It was
clearly evident to
anyone who wanted to take a look.
Trends exist.
Call it information cascades; call it
momentum. Whatever you choose to
call it, know that trends are how
humans conduct business, and always
have. Life is not chaos. Civilization
is when we impose some type of order
on the otherwise chaotic state of
Nature.
Therefore,
the moral of the story is to keep your
money in the strongest stocks at all
times. That's the most intelligent way
to approach investing in the stock
market. And forget trying to be randomly
average. It doesn't satisfy.
FOR
THE WEEK...still
looking for a bottom
Pretty
much a digestion of the bounce back
after the stabilization after the
wipeout. Most indices have moved back
up into areas of resistance. The
resistance for the Dow isn't as
formidable as it is for NASDAQ. A
summer rally must somehow mount an
offensive to eat through these
barriers, if it is to happen at these
levels. If it can't do it, the market
will have to drop lower in order to
find sufficient buying interest.
Gradually rising interest rates don't
help.
Metals & Mining had a good week to
add to its commanding lead over the
rest of the pack. Air Freight helped
Transportation to move into the #2
spot. Aerospace/Defense continued to
bounce around in the Top Five, holding
strong at #3. Manufacturing came in at
#4 and Automotive held tight at #5.
Gambling kept Leisure in the Top Ten
at #6. A big drop for the week for #7
Real Estate wasn't enough to knock it
out of the Top Ten. But a few more
weeks like this and we'll be saying
"bye-bye." Energy made a big
comeback after two week's absence. The
#8 position might not be much more
than a bounce if the charts don't firm
up. Media had a bad week but
maintained position #9. Food &
Beverage rounded out the Top Ten by
being its usual "do-nothing"
self.
THE
TOP TEN...
|
Sector |
23Dec05
to
23Jun06 |
Week
of
23Jun 06 |
Visual
Chartist Commentary
|
|
Metals
& Mining |
+16.92%
|
+2.40% |
A
very strong week. Most groups
are right at or just below
support, except the
super-strong Iron & Steel,
which remains well above its
support. So far, the backing
and filling is healthy, but we
have to remind ourselves that
all stocks here have had
tremendous runs and are now
experiencing significant
retrenchments. The quality of
any rallies must be watched
carefully. And, as always,
keep in mind the risk/reward
metric of all Simplespreads.
If you've made a large portion
of your max profit and there
is still a lot of time to go,
then look seriously at closing
out the trade, taking your
profit, and retiring to the
sidelines. The risk/reward
metric of each trade is the
most important determinant of
whether you should stay in the
game or take the money and
run. |
|
Transportation |
+10.97% |
+2.70% |
A
super week. Airlines and
Railroads still in uptrends.
Air Freight stocks, bouncing
off support, just like they're
supposed to, had a fantastic
week, aided by FedEx's
reporting of superlative
earnings. Other companies in
the Air Freight business also
showed strong gains, some up
over 6% in one week.
|
|
Aerospace/Defense
|
+9.83% |
-1.32% |
Not
many stocks in this strong
group. The strongest are the
big defense contractors which
are behemoths who move slowly
and deliberately. No
volatility here, so not much
for Simplespreaders. |
|
Manufacturing |
+6.63% |
+0.72% |
Not
much of interest here right
now. Many stocks look good,
but have low volatility. Also,
the whole sector doesn't have
that many option-related
stocks. The sector does hold
promise for the future so we
should keep our eyes on it.
|
|
Automotive
|
+6.28% |
+0.68%
|
Dull,
duller, and dullest. The
sector has held up but offers
little of interest.
|
|
Leisure
|
+4.14% |
+0.01% |
Traveling,
eating, and gambling continue
to pace this sector. Some
interesting situations
developing here if at the
right price at the right time
and with the right
option. |
|
Real
Estate
|
+3.94% |
-1.21%
|
REITs
still holding. But no interest
to Simplespreaders.
|
|
Energy
|
+3.70% |
+1.32% |
As
much as we've loved this
sector for 2 years, we don't
like the fact that many of the
charts are tilting over to the
right, meaning they're having
a hard time rallying back up
to previous highs. A warning
sign for sure. But it was a
slick ride while it lasted.
Hopefully, they can regain
past glory. When they're good,
they're very good, but when
they go bad, they can really
hurt. Watch closely and monitor
any positions daily.
|
|
Media
|
+3.21% |
-1.31%
|
The
fact that the sector flamed out
last week right at its previous
multi-year highs does not make
for the best of conditions.
Needs more work, although it's
good to see the sector finally
show some strength.
|
|
Food
& Beverage |
+3.04% |
+0.72% |
Repeat
last week's comments: From
the looks of the stocks, the
depression is already here.
Only alcoholic-related
consumption is showing any
signs of strength.
|
|
AND THE
REST... |
|
Utilities
|
+2.65% |
-0.74%
|
Foreign
utilities holding sector up. The
rest of the group is
"winning" by not
losing. Not much here.
|
|
Tobacco
|
+1.94% |
0.00%
|
Relatively
dull stocks with little
movement.
|
|
Conglomerates
|
+1.82% |
-0.45%
|
Not
much going on here.
|
|
Dow
Jones Industrial Avg.
|
+1.43% |
-0.23%
|
Stuck
in "no man's land."
Sitting on top of support that
keeps getting weaker. However,
it is making a stand
here, and from a longer term
perspective, you have to admit
that the trend is still (barely)
up. The past few days have seen
some improvement in the
Soldier's actions, meaning maybe
the General's gallant leadership
is beginning to carry over to
the troops. This lackluster
action was expected in light of
the technical damage done
recently.
|
|
Telecommunications
|
+0.92% |
-0.45%
|
This
is a sector that hasn't shown
any leadership since early 2004.
The past few month's improvement
catches our attention so we plan
to keep our eyes on it.
|
|
Banking
|
+0.76% |
-0.91%
|
Usually
wise to avoid. Lack of
volatility.
|
|
Diversified
Services
|
+0.45% |
+0.48%
|
Consistently
an also-ran. Usually shows compatibility
with high tech, which is dead
right now.
|
|
Chemicals
|
+0.26% |
+0.35%
|
A
flash in the pan a few weeks back,
then died.
|
|
Retail
|
+0.02% |
-0.33%
|
Department
Stores still holding the group
up. Anything to do with the home
is flat on its back.
|
|
Specialty
Retail
|
-0.26% |
-0.10%
|
Group
1 Automotive, which shot from
$30 to $60 during January to
May, is now falling back, and
with it comes the whole sector.
|
|
Consumer
Durables
|
-0.27% |
+0.35%
|
Nothing
to look at here.
|
|
Consumer
Non-Durables
|
-0.51% |
+0.38%
|
Continuing
to be a
big disappointment. Don't know
why. Doesn't make any
difference, either. If it can't
perform, it can't perform. So,
we have no interest.
|
|
Drugs
|
-0.65% |
-0.64%
|
Disappointment
of the week. What will it take
to get this sector moving?
|
|
Insurance
|
-1.50% |
-0.46%
|
Hopefully
this sector is not waiting for
another hurricane which put some
wind beneath its wings...like
last year...but for only a few
months.
|
|
Financial
Services |
-1.66% |
+0.40% |
One
of the best places to have
been from last October to this
May, but since then -
disaster. |
|
Computer
Software & Svcs |
-1.78% |
+1.25% |
Weakness
all around. Some areas are
sitting at or near supports
and need to rally from here to
keep support from turning into
resistance. |
|
Electronics |
-2.91% |
-0.70% |
Having
failed at the 2002 and 2004
highs in April, and now
retreating back down to
support, we must watch for any
signs of strength. If not,
only bad things can continue
to happen. So, will support
hold, or not? |
|
Wholesale |
-3.89% |
-0.97% |
Not
much to interest
Simplespreaders here. |
|
Computer
Hardware |
-4.04% |
-1.04% |
Since
Apple went rotten in January
at $85 after its two year run
from $8, it's been nothing but
the Blue Screen of Death for
this sector. Some areas are
barely holding at support.
Now, if only the relative
strength weren't so bad. |
|
Materials
& Construction |
-6.61% |
+1.10% |
Plenty
of upside bounce-back room
here that won't mean anything.
This sector has a mountain to
climb before it can look
investable again. |
|
Health
Services |
-7.98% |
-0.39% |
Just
when you think the sector
might be able to get on its
feet and escape the terminal
ward, it practically dies
again. |
|
Internet |
-10.96% |
+2.59% |
A
good week. Now, we need a couple
dozen more. |
|
Statistical
Data: TeleChart 2005 |
|